Skip to main content

a book review: the reader

i'm not sure how i ended up with a copy of bernhard schlink's "the reader" on my shelf, but there it was, and, looking for something to read this weekend, i picked it up and read it.  in one 24 hour period.

it's not that it is that gripping, but that it is indeed that short.  i don't know what the official literary distinction is between a novel and a short story, but this must be near the boundary lands.

however, just because it is short doesn't mean it doesn't pack a punch.  it does.  and, in my opinion, it lands said punch right to the gut with powerful force.

i knew nothing about this book going into it, but i must offer full disclosure at this point that the first part of the book details a love affair between a 37-year old woman and a 15-year boy.  while it is certainly consensual, the law doesn't allow for consensual sex with a 15-year old, and so it should be clear that this is an illegal act, and that sexual abuse, in any of its many forms, is always terribly damaging and wrong.

that being said, literature has the unique opportunity to disentangle itself from things like laws in order to capture a particular moment, a particular life, and a particular story.  that isn't to say that the book is without morals.  on the contrary, morality is one of the main themes of the book, particularly as it is manifested in guilt; personal guilt, relational guilt, and national guilt.

the book is divided into three parts: first, michael (15) and and hanna's (37) initial relationship in germany; second, michael's time in law school, observing a trial in which hanna is a defendant; and third, michael's years as a law scholar, and his struggles with guilt (i have deliberately not given away the great secret of the book here, so you'll have to read for yourself to discover the twist).

in the second part of the book we discover that hanna had been involved in some terrible atrocities at concentration camps during the holocaust.  as she is being questioned by a judge about what she did and did not do, she asks a poignant question; a question, which, for me, seemed to be the echoing point of the book: what would you have done?

the book forces us to ask that question.  to germans, blaming their parents for the holocaust, it forces them to ask themselves, "what would you have done?"  to us, hiding our own dirty secrets from one another, it asks, in the midst of our guilt, "what would you have done?"

because of this enduring question, and it's handling of the idea of guilt, i rather liked this book, but i won't say that i loved it, or couldn't put it down.  i also don't think i'll ever read it again.  it is written in an easy-to-read way (other than some of the law portions, which, at least for me, dragged a bit), and is so very brief.  in the end, i give it 4 stars.  i think it is worth the read to help the reader ask some important questions about morality and guilt.  and, at a less meaningful but more accessible level, it promotes this wonderful love of reading, which is contagious and satisfying to me, the reader.


peggy said…
I read the book with a book club about 12 years ago. Though a short story with some difficult subject matter, parts of the story stuck with me for a long time after. I haven't thought about it for years until I read your review .. I enjoyed your observations. One part of the book that really touched me was near the end when Michael saw Hanna again for the first time in so many years. When people age together in loving, functional relationships sometimes it's as if nothing has changed. When Michael saw Hanna at the end, he just saw an old lady. Was this closure? Or more pain? “Desires, memories, fears, passions form labyrinths in which we lose and find and then lose ourselves again.”

Popular posts from this blog


i made these comments and prayed the following prayer at one of our worship services at SPWF yesterday, and had a few folks asked if i would post them, so there they are: 
It has been a season of terrible tragedy.  And I have noticed in the news a trending phrase: thoughts and prayers.  It even has its own hashtag on twitter and other social media, but net necessarily in a good way.  People are understandably tired of hearing about others’ thoughts and prayers, when that is only a thinly-veiled way of saying that our only obligation to those who suffer is a brief moment of silence, or nothing more than a tweet or public statement.  The truth is that, for those of us who follow Jesus, much is required when our neighbors suffer.  We are called to do justice where we can, to love kindness and mercy, and to walk with God through it all.  But let us be careful not to throw out the proverbial baby with the bathwater.  We are, as people of faith, those who know that prayer is not simply an em…

a divided tree

there is a tree in my back yard.  i'm pretty sure it's an oak tree.  at least that's what i think Shannon told me.  i don't know my oaks from my maples, my elms from my locusts.  to me, it's a tree: a corinthian column bursting up into life and glory.  full of sap and pulp and rings and bugs and cells pulsing with water and always reaching for something.  it is full of rhythm, reach and flourish then fall and die, and repeat. 

this particular tree, though, isn't of one mind. 

half of it's rusted orange leaves have given up their grip and surrendered -gracefully or not - to the pull of gravity and the threat of winter.  the north side of this inauspicious oak is just about bare naked, all sticks and straight lines, a skeleton of itself.  but the side that looks south is stubbornly resisting change.  no longer green, the leaves have compromised their summer vibrancy, but they are clearly not ready to concede death just yet. 

i feel like i can relate to this …

thankful right now

"if the only prayer you ever say in your life is 'thank you,' it will be enough." -Meister Eckhart

"thanksgiving is inseparable from prayer." -John Wesley

i've been thinking about gratitude quite a bit this week, and how to foster a thankful spirit in the midst of the barrage of bad news that for me is punctuated by yet another "breaking news" notification on my phone, interrupting the busyness of my day to rudely remind me that the world's brokenness knows nothing of limits or boundaries, not to mention my schedule or sanity.  still, the bad news keeps coming. 

i just scrolled through my most recent notifications just from the last few days and they contain phrases like "crimes against humanity," "57 million users hacked, but not reported," "alleged pattern of sexual abuse," and "extremely disturbing," just to name a few.  how am i supposed to be present at a staff meeting when my phone is buzzing …