Skip to main content

too heavenly minded?

"don't be so heavenly minded that you're no earthly good." 

ever hear that expression?  i have been pondering it a bit recently, and wanted to know what you think about it.  i have been reading several bloggers and others who react negatively to that sentiment, and who argue that it is impossible to be too heavenly minded.  they say we are supposed to be heavenly minded, that scripture tells us to have the mind of Christ. 

i certainly understand that, but i have always understood it a bit differently.  i always thought that the expression was literally talking about being "heavenly minded," that is, too preoccupied with heaven.  haven't you ever encountered a person of faith who was perhaps a bit too preoccupied with the afterlife?  or maybe you yourself have been?  i have.

i remember a season of my faith journey, when i was in high school, which was consumed with where i would go when i died.  i had a very legalistic faith at that time, and i truly believed that God was tallying my sin like a cosmic scorekeeper, and that i had better convince my sins regularly lest i die in some freak accident with an unconfessed sin, and end up burning for eternity in hell.  this fear literally drove me.  it guided me.  it was a prime mover in my faith, causing me to be incredibly concerned with right behavior.  i spent hours and hours trying to discern what words were okay to say, and which ones weren't; what things were okay to do with a girl, and which things weren't.  i spent an equal amount of time wrestling with guilt associated with all of this.  all of this spent time left me very little time for actually putting my faith into action.  in fact, one could argue that my faith was pretty much paralyzed by a performance issue.  i was worried about heaven and hell, so i became consumed with living correctly, which paradoxically, kept me from living the way Jesus clearly called us to live.  in short, i wasn't loving anyone besides perhaps myself.  this is not the Way Jesus describes in the gospel. 

i was so heavenly minded that i was no earthly good.  i think sometimes people also get too caught up on the glories to come, that they arren't willing to get their hands dirty in the world that is.  so i find that on both ends of this spectrum (heaven and hell) we can find ourselves too caught up in the afterlife to experience the abundant life that Jesus offers to us right here, right now.  frederick buechner writes, "you do not love God and live for him so you will go to heaven.  whichever side of the grave you happen to talking about, to love God and live for him is heaven." 

so those are my thoughts on the issue.  on this october wednesday, i'm just wondering what you think.  hit me up with a comment to let me know. 


Anonymous said…
I feel sometimes we use this topic for an excuse to make ourselves feel better. We see someone living a life where everything is centered on Christ and we don't want to give up some of our wordly ways so we say that that person is "too heavenly minded".
Emoly said…
well I won't get a discussion started on my thoughts because I always thought of it the same way as you, greg. I'm glad you made the opposing point because I had never thought of it like that before. It won't change how I think of the term. I will continue thinking about it the same way.
Anonymous said…
When I think of that phrase, I think of people (like the Pharisees of Jesus' time) who spent an abundance of time studying theology (they feel they are above just reading the Bible itself) and yet they can't seem to apply much more than "rules" to their own lives. Their kids are unruly, their marriages are a mess, and they are usually too lazy to provide for their families.

I honestly never really thought the phrase meant: "too focused on the after-life", but in some cases that might be true. I know of more than one fellow personally who thought that "since the world's coming to an end soon anyway, I really don't have to be concerned about caring for my family or paying my bills..." Obviously that phrase could apply to those people.

Obviously we can't be thinking about pleasing God and striving to please God too much. But if we are neglecting our families (thus disobeying God) in order to do "churchy" things or bury our noses in theology books 24/7, we are inviting this phrase to be said about us.

Popular posts from this blog


i made these comments and prayed the following prayer at one of our worship services at SPWF yesterday, and had a few folks asked if i would post them, so there they are: 
It has been a season of terrible tragedy.  And I have noticed in the news a trending phrase: thoughts and prayers.  It even has its own hashtag on twitter and other social media, but net necessarily in a good way.  People are understandably tired of hearing about others’ thoughts and prayers, when that is only a thinly-veiled way of saying that our only obligation to those who suffer is a brief moment of silence, or nothing more than a tweet or public statement.  The truth is that, for those of us who follow Jesus, much is required when our neighbors suffer.  We are called to do justice where we can, to love kindness and mercy, and to walk with God through it all.  But let us be careful not to throw out the proverbial baby with the bathwater.  We are, as people of faith, those who know that prayer is not simply an em…

a divided tree

there is a tree in my back yard.  i'm pretty sure it's an oak tree.  at least that's what i think Shannon told me.  i don't know my oaks from my maples, my elms from my locusts.  to me, it's a tree: a corinthian column bursting up into life and glory.  full of sap and pulp and rings and bugs and cells pulsing with water and always reaching for something.  it is full of rhythm, reach and flourish then fall and die, and repeat. 

this particular tree, though, isn't of one mind. 

half of it's rusted orange leaves have given up their grip and surrendered -gracefully or not - to the pull of gravity and the threat of winter.  the north side of this inauspicious oak is just about bare naked, all sticks and straight lines, a skeleton of itself.  but the side that looks south is stubbornly resisting change.  no longer green, the leaves have compromised their summer vibrancy, but they are clearly not ready to concede death just yet. 

i feel like i can relate to this …

thankful right now

"if the only prayer you ever say in your life is 'thank you,' it will be enough." -Meister Eckhart

"thanksgiving is inseparable from prayer." -John Wesley

i've been thinking about gratitude quite a bit this week, and how to foster a thankful spirit in the midst of the barrage of bad news that for me is punctuated by yet another "breaking news" notification on my phone, interrupting the busyness of my day to rudely remind me that the world's brokenness knows nothing of limits or boundaries, not to mention my schedule or sanity.  still, the bad news keeps coming. 

i just scrolled through my most recent notifications just from the last few days and they contain phrases like "crimes against humanity," "57 million users hacked, but not reported," "alleged pattern of sexual abuse," and "extremely disturbing," just to name a few.  how am i supposed to be present at a staff meeting when my phone is buzzing …